Article hero

Tender or Auction: Which Sale Method Is Right For You?

July 2026


By Claire Handel, Apprentice Rural Surveyor
 
When selling rural property or agricultural land, choosing the right method of sale can make a significant impact on the outcome. Two popular options are sale by tender and sale by auction, each offering different benefits depending on the property and the seller’s objectives.

Both methods set a firm timetable and bring buyers to a decision point, which is why both are widely used for farms, land and rural homes. Where they differ is in how bids are made, when the sale becomes legally binding and how much flexibility you keep as the seller. This guide explains how each works, compares them side by side and sets out the questions worth asking before you decide.
 

What is Selling by Tender?

Selling by tender invites interested buyers to submit written offers by a specified deadline. As bids remain confidential, prospective buyers are encouraged to put forward their strongest offer from the outset.

The property is usually marketed for a set period, with viewings arranged before the closing date. Buyers then return a tender form stating their offer, how they intend to fund the purchase and any conditions attached. Once the deadline passes, the offers are opened and weighed up side by side.
 

Informal and formal tenders

There are two types of tender, and the difference matters:
 
  • Informal tender: offers are not legally binding. Once you choose a buyer, the sale proceeds “subject to contract” in the same way as a private treaty sale. You are not obliged to accept the highest offer, or any offer, and you can negotiate further with the bidders.
  • Formal tender: each tender form is accompanied by a signed contract and a deposit. When you accept a bid, contracts are exchanged and both parties are legally committed, with completion on a date fixed in the tender documents. Because buyers are signing up to the contract with their bid, they need the legal paperwork in advance to carry out their checks, so more preparation is required up front.

Formal tenders are rarely seen these days. Informal tenders are the usual choice for rural property, as they combine a clear deadline with flexibility for the seller.
 

A tender sale may be suitable if:

  • You would prefer a confidential bidding process.
  • The property is expected to attract interest from multiple purchasers.
  • You want flexibility when choosing a purchaser, as the highest offer is not always the one accepted.
  • You want to set a clear timescale for receiving offers.
Key point for buyers: Submit a single, fixed figure. A bid framed by reference to other offers, such as “£1,000 more than the highest other offer”, is known as a referential or escalating bid. In the leading case on sealed bids, Harvela Investments v Royal Trust Co of Canada, the House of Lords held in 1985 that a referential bid was not a valid offer, because confidential bidding only works if every offer stands on its own as a fixed sum.

What is Selling by Auction?

Selling by auction invites buyers to bid openly against one another on a set date. If the reserve price is met, the successful bidder exchanges contracts immediately when the hammer falls, creating a legally binding sale.

Ahead of the sale, the auctioneer publishes a guide price and a legal pack so that buyers can view the property, complete their due diligence and arrange finance before bidding. The reserve, the minimum figure you will accept, is agreed privately between you and the auctioneer. Under the RICS professional standard for auctioneers, the existence of a reserve must be disclosed to buyers but its amount stays strictly confidential, and the auctioneer cannot sell below it.

On the day, the buyer pays a deposit, normally 10% of the price, and completion follows on the date set in the auction conditions, typically around four weeks later. RICS also requires any buyer’s premium or administration charge to be stated in the catalogue from the start of marketing, so buyers can work out their full costs.

At GTH, land and property can be sold at our traditional property and land auctions, held at venues across the South West, where buyers can bid in the room, online or by phone. We also run online timed auctions, where a property can be listed and sold at any time rather than waiting for a set sale date. Results from our 2025 auctions included 6.75 acres of woodland at Hinton Blewett, guided at £60,000 and sold for £106,000, and 2.30 acres of pastureland near Axbridge, guided at £50,000 and sold for £89,000.
 

An auction may be the right choice if:

  • You are looking to achieve a sale within a defined timeframe.
  • Competitive bidding is likely to generate increased buyer interest.
  • You want certainty once a successful bid has been accepted.
  • You value a transparent process, where every buyer can see the bidding as it happens.

Tender and Auction Compared

The table below summarises the main practical differences. The exact terms will always depend on the particulars and contract for each sale.
 
  Informal tender Formal tender Auction
How offers are made Confidential written offers by a deadline Confidential written offers with a signed contract by a deadline Open bidding in the room, online or by phone
Can buyers see other bids? No No Yes
When it becomes binding On exchange of contracts after the usual conveyancing When the seller accepts a tender When the hammer falls at or above the reserve
Seller’s choice of buyer Full: any offer, or none Can accept any tender, or none Highest bid at or above the reserve
Certainty for the seller Lower until exchange High once accepted High once sold

 

Questions to Ask Before You Decide

Every property and every seller is different, but these questions usually point towards the right method:
 
  • Who are the likely buyers? Where a neighbouring farmer, a local developer or several known parties are likely to compete, a tender can draw out their best figure in confidence. Where demand is broad or hard to predict, an auction lets the market set the price in the open.
  • How important is certainty? An auction gives you a binding contract when the hammer falls, and a formal tender as soon as you accept a bid. An informal tender keeps more flexibility, but a buyer can still withdraw before exchange.
  • Is the land being sold in lots? Both methods can offer a farm as a whole or in separate lots. A tender lets you set the best offer for the whole against the combined offers for individual lots before you commit either way.
  • Is anything unusual about the property? Overage clauses, rights of way, tenancies, environmental agreements or development potential can make buyers want to negotiate terms, which an informal tender allows and an auction does not.
  • How much preparation is possible before launch? An auction or formal tender needs the legal paperwork ready at the start of marketing, so you will need your solicitor involved early.

Preparing for Either Method

Whichever route you take, a well-prepared sale gives buyers the confidence to bid strongly. Gather title documents, plans, any tenancy or environmental agreements and details of services and access before you launch. Our guide to preparing a farm for sale covers this in more detail.

Buyers should also expect identity checks. Under HMRC’s anti-money laundering guidance, estate agents and auctioneers must carry out customer due diligence on both the seller and the buyer, and auctioneers must complete these checks on a buyer before a binding contract is entered into. This is one reason bidders are often asked to register before the sale.

If you are leaning towards auction, our guide to selling at auction explains guide prices, reserves and what happens on the day.
 

Which option is best?

There is no one-size-fits-all approach. The most suitable sale method will depend on the type of property being sold, current market conditions and your individual objectives.

Seeking advice from an experienced rural surveyor can help you determine the sales method that is most likely to achieve the best outcome for your property. In some cases the answer is neither, and a private treaty sale with negotiated offers will suit the property and the likely buyers best.
 

Frequently Asked Questions

Is an offer made by tender legally binding?

It depends on the type of tender. Offers made by informal tender are not binding and the sale proceeds subject to contract. A formal tender includes a signed contract and deposit, so the sale becomes binding as soon as the seller accepts it.
 

What happens if the reserve is not reached at auction?

The auctioneer cannot sell below the reserve, so the property is not sold under the hammer. You can then discuss next steps with your auctioneer, such as considering offers after the sale or remarketing the property.
 

Do I have to accept the highest tender?

No. Tender documents normally state that the seller is not bound to accept the highest or any offer, which allows you to weigh up the buyer’s position, funding and conditions alongside the price.
 

Talk to Our Farm Agency Team

If you have an agricultural property or land to sell, our Farm Agency team can advise on the right method of sale and provide a free valuation. For advice on our broader range of rural and professional services, please contact your local GTH office today.
 

Related News